Early Awareness Policy

College Access and Success Strategies That Promote Early Awareness in Middle-Level Grades

Carrie Warick, Director of Policy and Advocacy; Paula Acevedo, Former Graduate Intern; Allie Ciaramella, Communications Manager; and Lisa King Consulting, Inc. 

In follow up on the literature review below, NCAN delved into policy strategies that promote early awareness for middle grade students. This white paper offers guidance on how to equitably design children's savings accounts, early commitment scholarships, place-based promise programs, and informational campaigns to best serve low-income populations of families with middle grade students. Similar to the findings in the literature review, there is not enough evidence to suggest that one of these strategies works over the other; however, each presents evidence that it is a promising practice to increase the likelihood of college going and success for low-income and first-generation students. 

 

What Does the Research Say about Early Awareness Strategies for College Access and Success?
Elizabeth Glaser, Graduate Research Assistant; and Carrie Warick, Director of Partnerships and Policy

Postsecondary early awareness strategies are a fast-growing component of college access to attainment efforts. Broadly defined, these programs and policies encourage low-income and first-generation students to gain the information, skills, and resources they need to successfully take part in higher education. They focus on students in fifth through eighth grades, to communicate that education beyond high school is an option, and to help them understand the steps they must take to prepare. This report includes a literature review of the current research on Early Awareness. The evidence suggests that a variety of early awareness program models can be successful, but at varying degrees and with a wide range in cost.

A secondary goal emerged during evaluation of available early awareness research: to encourage additional rigorous, longitudinal evaluations of early awareness programs. The majority of early awareness interventions are at the state and local level, and the quantity and quality of program reviews vary greatly. In some cases within this paper, we rely on data from internal evaluation or qualitative information due to a lack of data from controlled evaluation methods. In particular, it is difficult to measure the effectiveness of early awareness programs and their end goal -matriculation and attainment in higher education - because of additional interventions and factors that students experience during high school. Additionally, following students from their time in early awareness programs throughout their time in higher education requires more than a decade of longitudinal tracking. Interim success outcomes, such as enrolling in college preparatory curriculum or taking standardized tests in junior year, should be considered.

While the research demonstrates that early awareness strategies should continue to be part of the college access and success continuum, it is also clear that any intervention should be designed with specific indicators and outcome measures. Additionally, policy-makers should be wary of any one particular program or intervention that promises to be a silver bullet and rather view early awareness strategies as the first step of an integrated plan for student success.

DOWNLOAD RESOURCE COMPENDIUM

 

To learn more about individual Early Awareness programs not outlined in the report, visit the NCAN Blog and select the "Early Awareness" filter.


Download NCAN Presentations on Early Awareness Policy:

SREB/GO Alliance Webinar

College Board Forum

NCAN National Conference